buy cheap autodesk autocad map 3d 2010 buy cheap propellerhead reason 4 buy cheap visio 2013 cheap autodesk revit architecture 2011 download microsoft visual studio ultimate 2013 best price lynda com running a design business designer client agreements buy cheap online microsoft office 2011 mac buy cheap online a1click ultra pc cleaner download karelia software sandvox 2 buy cheap online adobe edge animate cc 2015 purchase autodesk 3d studio max 2008 buy cheap online autodesk autosketch 9 cheap lynda com indesign tables in depth cheap divergent media clipwrap 2 discount eplan electric p8 buy lynda com object oriented programming with php good price autodesk inventor 2016 purchase roxio popcorn 4 buy alien skin exposure 5 cheap altova xmlspy 2009 lowest price lynda com linkedin essential training purchase microsoft office professional plus 2013 sp1 cheap dl creative photoshop cs4 digital illustration and art techniques apr 2009 1 ed low cost roxio toast 11 titanium buy infinite skills learning adobe photoshop cs6 training video low cost ntfs for mac buy adobe incopy cs6 discount adobe fireworks cs5 download autodesk autocad map 3d 2015 buy cheap lynda com access 2013 essential training buy cheap futuremark 3dmark 06 advanced buy apple mac os x 10 8 mountain lion order corel motion studio 3d good price agict adobe creative suite 4 design premium digital classroom jun 2009 1 ed buy microsoft office 2007 standart buy cheap online microsoft outlook 2016 cheap adobe photoshop lightroom 6 buy cheap online visio 2013 good price pitney bowes mapinfo pro 11 5 buy cheap online microsoft visual studio professional 2012 32 bit lowest price 1click dvd to ipod 2 download microsoft expression studio 4 web professional download dac building a web site 4 dummies jun 2010 4 ed buy adobe framemaker 9 cheap nik software hdr efex pro best price microsoft office 2007 home and student cheap siemens solid edge st7 buy cheap online spectrasonics trilian 1 4 1d buy online lynda com narrative portraiture on location in texas order rh de ce 6 5 discount micromat techtool pro 6 mac 64 bit order microsoft visio professional 2013 good price prodad heroglyph 4 pro buy online autodesk inventor professional 2015 buy cheap autodesk autocad civil 3d 2014 buy cheap navicat premium 9 buy navicat premium 9 lowest price parallels desktop 8 low cost micromat techtool pro 6 mac 64 bit buy cheap artlantis studio 5 lowest price parallels desktop 9 buy maxon cinema 4d r11 studio bundle buy microsoft expression studio 4 web professional order originlab originpro 8 good price microsoft office onenote 2010 low cost nuance paperport professional 12 1 buy microsoft office 2007 professional download forklift 2 5 best price microsoft project professional 2013 best price agile bits 1password 5 buy cheap online autodesk autocad electrical 2014 order autodesk autocad mechanical 2016 buy pixelmator low cost adobe captivate 5 5 buy intuit turbotax premier 2014 usa order autodesk autocad design suite standard 2013 buy infinite skills learning autodesk autocad 2014 buy autodesk autocad civil 3d 2014 buy cheap online apple final cut express 4 low cost microsoft office access 2007 best price solidworks 2013 premium buy microsoft streets and trips 2010 best price microsoft office publisher 2003 buy cheap online autodesk autocad lt 2014 discount maxon cinema 4d studio r16 purchase roxio toast 11 titanium best price lynda com creating infographics with illustrator buy cheap iexplorer 3 buy cheap online aaa logo 2010 business edition 3 purchase guitar pro 5 low cost iskysoft itube studio 5 buy online geometric camworks 2015 cheap microsoft autoroute 2010 europe buy cheap online graphisoft archicad 14 download lynda com ruby on rails 3 essential training buy cheap 3d home architect design suite deluxe 8 purchase lynda com indesign cs6 new features best price microsoft office visio professional 2003 good price roxio popcorn 4 buy online apple final cut studio 3 purchase adobe after effects cs3 professional low cost microsoft windows vista business low cost autodesk autocad architectire 2012 lowest price project 2013 buy lynda com ruby on rails 3 essential training cheap abest mpeg vcd dvd video converter buy online transoft aeroturn pro 5 order autodesk autocad design suite ultimate 2015 lowest price binaryfruit drivedx 1 2 buy cheap gibbscam 2014 download microsoft publisher 2016 buy online pragon camptune 8 download nik software color efex pro 3 buy apple mac os x 10 4 tiger low cost microsoft office visio standard 2010 buy cheap macrabbit cssedit 2 order eset smart security 5 cheap microsoft office powerpoint 2007 cheap daz carrara 8 pro good price cyberlink powerdirector 8 ultra discount autodesk autocad raster design 2014 low cost quarkxpress 10 buy autodesk autocad mep 2016 order microsoft publisher 2013 purchase alibre design expert 2012 best price eset smart security 5 order lynda com transforming a photo into a painting with photoshop cs6 good price microsoft office 2007 professional buy cheap autodesk impression 3 buy cheap corel windvd pro 11 cheap microsoft frontpage 2003 order macx video converter pro order microsoft office word 2007 buy cheap agict adobe creative suite 4 design premium digital classroom jun 2009 1 ed buy cheap adobe after effects cc 2015 low cost propellerhead reason 5 buy cheap online corel painter 12 buy cheap online prodad heroglyph 4 pro good price acdsee canvas 11 with gis module buy cheap online lynda com php with mysql beyond the basics best price navicat premium 9 best price autodesk revit 2014 order lynda com php with mysql essential training good price microsoft office powerpoint 2007 good price autodesk autocad civil 3d land desktop companion 2009 buy corel photoimpact x3 buy rosettastone hindi level 1 2 and 3 set buy online microsoft access 2016 purchase microsoft access 2016 lowest price avid media composer 5 best price anime studio pro 8 download adobe photoshop elements 6 discount camtasia studio 7 discount lynda com practical photoshop selections buy corelcad 2013 purchase iexplorer 3 discount ableton live 9 suite good price adobe fireworks cs5 discount adobe freehand mx cheap xilisoft hd video converter 6 good price busymac buy cheap nero 8 ultra edition buy cheap luxion keyshot pro 4 low cost capture nx 2 good price autodesk revit architecture 2011 cheap autodesk autocad lt 2011 download autodesk autocad revit architecture 2010 download divx pro 7 order autodesk softimage 2015 lowest price adobe after effects cs4 download microsoft windows 7 home premium family pack low cost telestream screenflow 3 download microsoft office 2011 mac lowest price lynda com outlook 2013 essential training best price autodesk autocad 2014 cheap microsoft visual studio premium 2013 purchase autodesk autocad electrical 2014 purchase zonealarm internet security suite 8 buy total media converter 2 buy cheap solidworks 2015 premium discount crossover 13 0 low cost adobe audition cs5 5 buy cheap nero 9 best price autodesk autocad lt 2009 low cost microsoft office onenote 2010 good price microsoft expression studio 4 web professional low cost luxion keyshot pro 4 buy cheap autodesk revit lt 2015 best price sony movie studio platinum 12 best price arts pdf aerialist professional order autodesk smoke 2012 best price stellar phoenix mac data recovery v4 order makemusic final 2012 cheap autodesk autocad civil 3d 2012 download microsoft windows vista ultimate download apple mac os x 10 8 mountain lion
Home Articles Current Feature Do Clothes Make the Woman?
Do Clothes Make the Woman?
Written by Jill Jackson   
Friday, 31 May 2013 17:42
“Women in Pants,” by Catherine Smith and Cynthia Graig
Dr. Mary Walker (1832-1919) was the first woman awarded the Congressional Medal of Honor for her work as a commissioned surgeon during the American Civil War. A strong proponent of women’s rights, she wore male attire throughout most of her life and was once arrested for doing so, as reported in the New York Times’ June 6, 1866, edition.
Thilges re-created Dr. Mary Walker’s bloomer or reform costume from a photo taken around 1886.
Often called “the forgotten women of the American Civil war,” female vivandière or cantineers dressed in similar uniforms as the regiments to which they were assigned. They supplied the “3 Ws” — whisky, wine, and water — to the fighting troops during battle. As volunteers, many fought alongside the men and were greatly admired for their bravery.
The preceding vintage photo and Joan Thilges’ doll costume shows a women in Zouave uniform, a style adopted by regiments on both sides of the war. The uniforms were based on those used by French soldiers during the Crimean War and earlier styles worn by North African recruits in the 1830s.
This photo postcard from 1915 shows rodeo perfomer Bonnie McCaroll. Whether performing as a bronco rider or taking on the role of a cowboy in the American West when men were not available or affordable, many women dressed in male attire out of necessity — skirts put them in danger of getting tangled in the stirrups or other gear. McCarroll died in 1929 after a bronco-riding exhibit in which her boot (not her pants) got caught in a stirrup.
The seated doll wears Thilges’ re-creation of Bonnie McCarrol’s wide pants; the other doll reproduces a cowgirl’s wooly chaps shown elsewhere in the book. The hats were created by Cassandra Coleman.
This photo, titled “A Group of Women Enjoying a Card Game,” is circa 1910. Women often enjoyed assuming male roles in which they were allowed freedoms of expression far beyond their normal social roles.
Julie Woodbury meticulously created the dolls’ attire for this reproduction of the original photograph. The garments are made of wool, silk, or brocade. Each one is fully lined, and vests and coats have functional buttonholes.
Not all cultures frowned on women wearing pants. This photo, from the 1860s or 1870s, of a wealthy Chinese woman, was shown to compare the limitations and pain of her “golden feet” to the effects of the restrictive corsets forced upon European and American women.
Thilges re-created the woman’s garment from a pair of 1920s Chinese-style pajamas.
“Women in Pants,” by Catherine Smith and Cynthia Graig
start stop bwd fwd

Do Clothes Make the Woman?

Wearing trousers is a fashion option taken for granted by most women in the 21st century, but it wasn’t so very long ago that females who wore bifurcated garments on their lower extremities in public were considered vulgar or indecent — and sometimes even unlawful!

By Jill Jackson

“It is in very bad taste, even for a frolic, for a woman to assume boys’ clothes, or get herself up in any way that will tend to make herself look masculine.”
— Practical Etiquette, 1899 quoted in “Women in Pants”

During Hollywood’s Golden Era, the l930s and ’40s, such movie stars as Kathryn Hepburn and Marlena Dietrich popularized the look of tailored slacks and sweaters, proving that pants could be not only practical but glamorous as well. “Downtown Abbey” fans may envision an even earlier time, when women donned “womanalls” to toil in factories as World War I created a shortage of male workers.

Go further back, and you’ll see that women have been wearing pants for centuries, despite society’s efforts to dissuade them. In the book “Women in Pants,” authors Catherine Smith and Cynthia Greig present a pictorial chronicle of women wearing trousers since at least the early 1800s.

Inspired by the vintage photos collected in the book, Joan Thilges, a doll collector, period fashion designer, and amateur historian, joined forces with Julie Woodbury to reproduce, in doll form, the forbidden ensembles worn by some of the book’s “manly maidens, cowgirls, and other renegades,” who posed for the camera in masculine attire, thereby opening themselves to censure. Why would they do such a thing? As the book itself explains, “For some, wearing pants was a necessity; for others, it was an act of defiance; for still others, it was just fun.”

Women in Pants
By Catherine Smith and Cynthia Graig
H.N. Abrams, 2003
184-page hardcover, $35
ISBN: 0-8109-4571-1

Doll photos by Joan Thilges
Vintage photos are reproduced with permission from “Women in Pants” co-author Catherine Smith
Excerpts from “Women in Pants” are used by permission of the authors


TrackBack URI for this entry

Comments (2)

Subscribe to this comment's feed
I always loved dolls especially when they depict an era of time.
I think women are beautiful people and although I personally love wearing pants for warmth, nothing looks nicer than a woman dressed in beautiful clothing.
alady' , September 14, 2013 | url
This was a fascinating article! Joan's work is amazing! Julie's too! I say that from personal experience as I own several of their fantastic creations. I really loved this article just wished it had tons more photos and had been longer. But very thrilled with what was shown.
Jay , September 13, 2013 | url

Write comment

smaller | bigger